the 6 questions I ask on page one


Hey Reader,

The past few years I haven't done my own Black Friday sales. Instead, I kept things low key and just shared the deals I like from other people (and I will still do that).

But this year I decided to bring back something I love and find that I miss doing, but haven't offered in over a year, and haven't opened to everyone in two years:

I'm once again offering critique and coaching spots, HALF OFF, through Monday, November 30.

Why now? Because these sessions are one of my favorite things in my business. I love meeting with authors, both new to me and ones I've worked with before, and helping you move your career forward and feel excited about publishing again.

So I'm offering them half off so I get a chance to work with more of you.

Before I tell you about it, I want to give you something useful to use, whether or not you ever book a session with me, because sure, this is a sales email, but that doesn't mean it can't also give you something to take away.

So to give you some insight into my process, and the chance to steal it for your own use, here are some of the questions I ask myself when I read someone's opening pages. To be fair, this is a little less a checklist of questions for me now, and more of an intrinsic understanding (that's what happens after 20+ years in publishing) but this is how I'm articulating some of them for your use, so you can start to incorporate them naturally over time too!

  • By the end of the first page, do I know whose story this is?
  • Do I know what they want, or what's wrong, soon enough to care?
  • Is this scene doing something important, or is it warming up, and taking too long to get somewhere?
  • Did I have to reread anything because I got lost?
  • Would I turn the page because I want to, or because I'm supposed to?
  • Do I feel connected to what's happening on page in some way? Is it through the character narrative, the events on page, the author voice, or something else?

Try them on your own pages this weekend. If your answers come easily, that's great. If you keep thinking "um, I think so?", that usually means you're too close to the book to see it.

Every author is too close to their own book. That's normal, and it's exactly what a second look from someone like me is for.

(Also, just so there's no confusion, if you buy a critique from me, you don't have to send opening pages. You can send pages from anywhere in the book! A moment of tension, a scene of dialogue, a critical moment, even a sex scene! The pages you choose are completely up to you.)

So here's what a critique looks like with me:

You send up to 5,000 words (or 4,000 plus your query letter or book description). I read closely, and then we talk for 30 minutes on Zoom. Half of that is me walking you through what's working and what isn't. The other half is yours to ask me anything about this book, your publishing path, or what comes next. Or choose a full 60 minutes for more time on your bigger questions. You get the recording and a follow-up PDF with a conversation recap and any suggested actions or next steps.

Through Monday, November 30, the sessions are half off:

  • Critique & Consultation: $200 (normally $400)
  • Critique & Consultation with a full 60-minute session: $250 (normally $500)

​Grab your critique spot here​

Not a Zoom person? I can record my critique for you, and we'll do a Q&A on Voxer instead (15 minutes for a 30-minute critique, 45 minutes for a 60-minute one).

And if you don't need feedback on pages, but you do need a plan, my coaching sessions are half off too:

  • 30 minutes on Zoom: $75 (normally $150)
  • 60 minutes on Zoom: $137.50 (normally $275)
  • 60 minutes on Voxer: $75 (normally $150). It's asynchronous, a thoughtful back and forth within a 60-minute time frame, not a continuous conversation.

You'll bring whatever you're trying to figure out, whether that's your publishing path, your plan for 2027, or what to do with a manuscript. Every coaching session comes with a follow-up PDF, and Zoom sessions are recorded.

There are 15 spots total across critique and coaching, because fifteen is what I can manage and do well between now and the end of January. Once they're gone, they're gone. Otherwise, the sale ends November 30th at 11:59pm Eastern.

When you buy, you’ll get my calendar link to book an open time between December 1 and January 31. (I’m taking Christmas week off, so no sessions December 21 to 27.) Your session needs to happen by January 31. After that, unused sessions expire.)

Hit reply if you're not sure which option makes sense for where you are. I'll give recommendations for the best fit (or tell you if none of them fit at all).

~Angela

P.S. Don't want any more emails about this sale? Click here and I'll leave you out of the rest. You'll still get my regular emails.

Angela James

Join my newsletter for publishing, writing and marketing tips and advice! Angela James (she/her) is a #1 New York Times bestselling fiction freelance editor and author career coach, and has enjoyed two decades in genre fiction publishing. She's edited bestselling books and authors, including the #1 New York Times bestselling Paper Princess by Erin Watt, as well as hundreds of other authors such as Mariah Stewart, Shelly Laurenston/G.A. Aiken, A.C. Arthur, Jaci Burton, Ilona Andrews, Alexa Riley, Lilith Saintcrow, Josh Lanyon, K.A. Mitchell, Shannon Stacey, and more. She is also the creator of Before You Hit Send: a popular online self-editing and writing workshop as well as Book Boss: From Written to Recommended, a supportive and growing author community. For more information about Angela’s freelance editorial and consulting services visit angelajames.co.

Read more from Angela James

Hey Reader, Longtime readers might remember when I used to do the 3@3. New readers, welcome to the explanation: a few years back, I used to go live once a week at 3pm and answer 3 questions that had been pre-submitted. It was all live, no editing, just raw talk. Turns out, I've got a pile of those clips sitting around, and honestly, most of the advice hasn't aged a day. Would I add some information or say it a bit different? Maybe. But these are still so solid, I decided to resurrect them and...

Hey Reader, Longtime readers might remember when I used to do the 3@3. New readers, welcome to the explanation: a few years back, I used to go live once a week at 3pm and answer 3 questions that had been pre-submitted. It was all live, no editing, just raw talk. Turns out, I've got a pile of those clips sitting around, and honestly, most of the advice hasn't aged a day. Would I add some information or say it a bit different? Maybe. But these are still so solid, I decided to resurrect them and...

Hey Reader, November is historically NaNoWriMo month. Now that the official official NaNo isn't around any more, I haven't heard as many people talking about it, but it seems as if some writers still reserve November for a major push to get massive word count in. If you started on November 1st, that means you're on day 9 or, as I like to call it: the week 2 wall. Anyone who's ever run (or participated in) a challenge knows how this goes... Week 1: everyone starts out strong, full of...